A song first recorded in 1959 became Paul Revere & The Raiders’ only No. 1 hit more than a decade later — and its path to the top was stranger than the record label suggested.

Paul Revere & The Raiders • “Indian Reservation” • 1971

A Song With a Long History

“Indian Reservation” began long before Paul Revere & The Raiders recorded it. Written by John D. Loudermilk, the song was first recorded by Marvin Rainwater in 1959 under the title “The Pale Faced Indian.” Years later, British singer Don Fardon turned it into a hit, reaching No. 20 on the Billboard Hot 100 in 1968 and later No. 3 in the United Kingdom.

The Raiders’ Biggest Hit Almost Wasn’t a Raiders Record

By 1970, the Raiders were trying to move beyond the image that had made them famous in the mid-1960s. Lead singer Mark Lindsay had already scored solo success, and “Indian Reservation” was originally recorded as another Lindsay solo single. Lindsay later said he cut the track with Los Angeles session musicians and produced it himself. Because the Raiders badly needed a hit, the recording was ultimately released under the group’s shortened name, “The Raiders.”

More Than 2 Million Copies — and No. 1

The decision changed the group’s history. “Indian Reservation (The Lament of the Cherokee Reservation Indian)” climbed to No. 1 on the Billboard Hot 100 for the week of July 24, 1971. It became the first and only Hot 100 chart-topper of the Raiders’ career. Contemporary music-industry coverage in Cash Box reported in August 1971 that the single had already sold more than two million copies. The record spent 22 weeks on the Hot 100.

How Many People Heard It?

There is no reliable way to calculate the exact number of individual listeners who heard the song in 1971. Radio airplay, television appearances, jukeboxes, and shared physical records were not tracked like modern streaming. But a No. 1 Billboard position, 22 weeks on the chart, and sales above two million copies show that the song reached a massive mainstream audience.

What the Song Was Trying to Say

The song presents a dramatic story of Cherokee dispossession, forced relocation, and the loss of language, customs, and identity. Its emotional power comes from the idea that a people can be pushed from their homeland but still hold on to who they are. That theme connected with listeners during an era when protest songs and songs about social injustice had become part of mainstream pop culture.

The History Behind the Message

The song should not be treated as a precise historical account. Cherokee history is far more complex than a three-minute pop record can capture. The Cherokee Nation documents the forced removal of thousands of Cherokee people from their southeastern homelands in 1838, an event now remembered as the Trail of Tears, during which roughly 4,000 Cherokee people died. Against that history, the song’s enduring message is less about literal detail than about displacement, cultural survival, and the refusal to forget.

Why It Still Stands Out

More than five decades later, the record remains unusual: it revived a band whose commercial momentum had faded, became their only No. 1 single, and was largely built around Mark Lindsay and studio musicians. What sounded like a comeback single was also, in a sense, a solo recording that became the biggest hit attached to the band’s name.

Listen on YouTube